That deeply personal and tragic connection
- May. 27th, 2018 at 10:20 AM
For me, in modern adventure/thriller storytelling, no trope feels trite, predictable, and frequently downright silly more often than the revelation that the protagonist has a deeply personal and preferably tragic connection to the story problem.
In the remake of THE MAGNIFICENT SEVEN (which I watched last night and that got me thinking about this), it turns out that Sam Chisholm is helping the beleaguered townspeople because Bartholomew Bogue's men previously raped his mom and killed his sisters.
In SPECTRE, it turns out that Ernst Stavro Blofeld has engineered all the world-shaking threats James Bond has faced through four movies because he's really Bond's resentful foster brother.
Do these revelations really strengthen the stories, or do they just seem contrived? I think the latter. I also think you can have a satisfying story where the protagonist does what he does simply because his sympathies have been engaged, he wants to get paid, or it's his job. Take, for example, the original MAGNIFICENT SEVEN or a whole lot of other 007 stories.
Now, with all that said, aspiring writers, there are clearly many agents, editors, and producers who believe the protagonist's deeply personal connection is exactly what a story needs to sing, so, hey, apply what I've said here with extreme caution. But, readers, I pledge to you that if I ever write a serious story about an Allied soldier fighting in World War II, he won't be on the battlefield because Hitler stole his bicycle when he was a kid.

Latest Month
January 2019 | ||||||
S | M | T | W | T | F | S |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | ||
6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 |
13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 |
20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 |
27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 |
Tags
- " humor
- "rooster rock
- 007
- 01 publishing
- 2014 tabletop awards
- aaron allston
- aaron allston's strike force
- abortion
- accursed
- accursed rpg
- accursed: the festival at glenelg
- adam-troy castro
- adult entertainment
- adventure
- adventure stories
- aeryn rudel
- aetaltis
- agent coulson
- agents of shield
- aging
- airlock alpha
- alan baxter
- aldo nadi
- aleister crowley
- alfred cloutier
- alien invasion fiction
- alien invasions
- aliens
- ama
- amazon
- american library association conference
- amy lauderback
- andrew zack
- android
- animated series
- anna smith-spark
- anthology
- anya martin
- ari marmell
- arkham horror
- arm cast
- armand rosamilia
- armand rosamilla
- arrow
- art
- astrojive
- audible
- audio drama
- audio play
- audiobook
- audiobooks
- autumn
- avengers
- avengers vs. x-men
- award
- awards
- away mission
- balathex
- barack obama
- bards
- basil & moebius
- basil and moebius
- batman
- batman v. superman: dawn of justice
- battlefield earth
- battleground games
- bebop
- before they knew him
- belinda thorne
- ben affleck
- ben bova
- best of 2012
- best of 2015
- bethany bare
- bill clinton
- bill hatfield
- bill willingham
- billy fox
- birthday
- black crowns
- black dogs
- black river irregulars
- blackguards
- blind god's bluff
- blood and ink
- blood sushi
- bombad radio
- bombard radio
- book giveaway
- book launch
- book list
- book recommendations
- book review
- booknapped
- books-a-million
- bop
- boycotts
- bram stoker awards
- bram stoker awards weekend
- breaking up is hard to do
- brew city gamers
- brian pettera
- brian setzer
- broken eye books
- brotherhood of the griffon
- bryan thomas schmidt
- buzzymag
- c. l. moore
- call of cthulhu
- called to darkness
- canice gormleigh
- caravan of shadows
- carcosa
- carol wolf
- cartoon network
- cat rambo
- caves
- champions of aetaltis
- charity
- charles r. rutlede
- charles r. rutledge
- charles rutledge
- charles stross
- chicon
- chris a. jackson
- chris jameson
- christine morgan
- christmas
- christopher golden
- christopher nolan
- chronicles of the demon lord
- clermont comic con
- cody goodfellow
- cohesion press
- collaboration
- collection
- comics
- competition
- conan
- conan the barbarian
- conjure
- conjure 2016
- constantine
- contest
- convention appearance
- conventions
- corey redekop
- cosmic horror
- cosplay
- cover art
- cover contest
- crawlspace
- creative loafing best of the bay awards
- crossing the streams
- crossroad press
- cthulhu
- cthulhu fhtagn
- cthulhu fhtagn!
- cthulhu mythos
- cw
- cyberpunk
- d&d next
- da vinci's demons
- daniel clowes
- daniel myers
- dark and stormy night
- dark fantasy
- dark fortune
- dark shadows
- dave gross
- david nickle
- david williams
- dc
- dc comics
- dead time
- dean samed
- death in the walled warren
- derrick ferguson
- diehard gamefan
- dirge
- dirge magazine
- donald j. bingle
- dr. metropolis
- dragon con
- dragons
- dread house
- dreamlands
- drivethrurpg
- drow
- dungeon crawler's radio
- dungeon crawlers radio
- dungeons & dragons
- dungeons and dragons
- earth station one
- ebook
- ed greenwood
- edgar rice burroughs
- editing
- eisner awards
- elaine cunningham
- elaine polk
- elder entertainment
- election
- elizabeth bear
- elizabeth bell
- elliott miller
- ender's game
- epic fantasy
- erik bear
- erik scott de bie
- erin evans
- erin m. evans
- ernst schrodinger
- fall of man
- fall of man rpg
- fan fiction
- fandom
- fans
- fantastic four
- fantasy
- fantasy flight games
- fantasy's scoundrels
- fencing
- fight scenes
- filk
- fire and fury
- forgotten realms
- free ebook
- free story
- from beyond
- gabrielle harbowy
- gahan wilson
- game-based fiction
- gamer's tavern
- games
- gaming
- gaming conventions
- garfunkel and oates
- gary phillips
- gay rights
- geeks of doom
- gen con
- gen con writer's symposium
- geoff brown
- geoff gander
- george soros
- ghost
- ghost hunting
- ghosts
- ghosts. undead
- gift ideas
- gilber gottfried
- gina x. grant
- gm's day
- gods and monsters
- google play
- gotham
- graphic audio
- graphic novel
- graphic novels
- graphicaudio
- gray mouser and fafhrd
- green lantern
- green ronin
- green ronin publishing
- greg bear
- gridlock
- grim dark
- grim tidings
- grimdark
- grimdark magazine
- gun control
- gun mage
- guns
- h. g. wells
- h. p. lovecraft
- hal greenberg
- hali
- halloween
- hank schwaeble
- haunted houses
- hedge witch
- hellmaw
- herbert west
- heroes of hollow earth
- heroic fantasy
- hillary clinton
- holidays
- hollywood
- horor
- horrified press
- horror
- horror fiction
- horror movies
- horror writers association
- humor
- hunger
- ian fleming
- indie publishing
- indiefab
- inspiration
- insurance
- intellectual property
- interview
- ire of the void
- iron fist
- iron kingdoms
- izombie
- j. m. martin
- j. r. r. tolkien
- jack the ripper
- james a. moore
- james bond
- james lovegrove
- james lowder
- james r. schmidt
- james r. tuck
- jamie stubkjaer
- javier zamora
- jaym gates
- jazz
- jeff strand
- jeremiah stewart
- jesse bullington
- jinx strange
- john carter
- john constantine
- john helfers
- john o'brien
- john palisano
- john shirley
- johnny depp
- jonathan maberry
- jonathan mayberry
- josh vogt
- joss whedon
- julie czerneda
- justice league
- kat rocha
- kathy nappier
- kelly jensen
- kelly swails
- ken spivey
- kickstarter
- kindle
- kindle countdown deal
- kindle worlds
- kirsten cross
- kryptonite
- l. frank baum
- l. ron hubbard
- laird barron
- larps
- larry correia
- larry hama
- lauren podolak
- leaves
- legacy of the reanimator
- legends of new pulp fiction
- libcon
- library of congress
- license expired
- license expired: the unauthorized james
- lionsgate
- locus
- locus bestseller list
- lore
- lost worlds
- lotto
- love
- lovecraftian tales
- lucy a. snyder
- luke scull
- lynne hansen
- m. todd gallowglas
- macabre ink
- madeline ashby
- magnetic press
- magnetic press. occultism
- malcolm mcdowell
- man of steel
- marc tassin
- marriage
- martian migraine press
- martin rivers
- martina migraine press
- marve's agents of shield
- marvel
- marvel comics
- marvel comics movies
- marvel's agent carter
- maxwell alexander drake
- mayan apocalypse
- mechanical muse
- mel gibson
- mel odom
- melanie meadors
- metrocon
- michael a/ stackpole
- michael bay
- michael hinman
- michael j. stackpole
- michael j. sullivan
- michael mcbride
- michael stackpole
- michael wolff
- michal ivan
- mike griffin
- milieux.com
- military horror
- mitch mcconnell
- mitchell brothers o'farrell theatre
- molly tanzer
- monsters
- morgan minor
- movie review
- movies
- movies airlock alpha
- murder in corvis
- mutants and masterminds
- mystery
- mythwits
- n. x. sharps
- narcissism
- nbc
- necronomicon
- necronomiocon
- neil sedaka
- netflix
- new pulp
- new pulp fiction
- new story
- new york times
- nicholas sansbury smith
- night shade books
- nikki howard
- nisaba
- no rest for the wicked
- nocturne travel agency
- noir
- nonbinary review
- nook
- novel
- npr
- nra
- oasis
- oasis 25
- oasis 26
- oasis 28
- occult
- odyssey con
- odyssey convention
- old dark house
- on a darkling plain
- on sale
- onder librum
- onder magazine
- online chat
- online puzzle game
- orlando
- orrin grey
- orson scott card
- owl goingback
- pacific rim
- paizo
- parody
- pathfinder
- pathfinder tales: called to darkness
- paul s. kemp
- paul vincenti
- percival constantine
- peter lee
- philip athans
- pinellas comic + maker con
- plagiarism
- plato
- podcast
- podcast interview
- podcast. the awakened
- podcasts
- point of view
- poker
- politics
- pony island adventures
- popular culture
- portal awards
- post-apocalyptic fiction
- press release
- previews
- privateer press
- privateer press audible
- pro se press
- pro se productions
- professor x
- project radio
- prologues
- promotion
- prophet of the dead
- public appearance
- publishing
- publishing will ludwigsen
- pulp ark
- pulp ark 2012
- pulp ark awards
- pulp fiction
- pulp hero fiction
- pulp heroes
- pulp magazines
- pulp never dies
- pulp talk
- pulp talk podcast
- pulped!
- pulped! podcast
- qatar
- r. a. salvatore
- r.p. l. johnson
- race
- racism
- radio
- ragnarok publications
- ramsey campbell
- rasputin
- raven love
- ray park
- read and feed america
- reanimator
- rebelmouse
- red kryptonite
- reddit ama
- rejection
- rejectomancy
- religion
- resonator
- resonator: new lovecraftian tales from b
- review
- reviewers
- reviews
- revision
- rewriting
- richard a. knaak
- rick wilber
- ride the star wind
- rise of the underdark
- rise phoenix studios
- risen phoenix studio
- rober j. schwalb
- robert e. howard
- robert j. schwalb
- robert w. chambers
- roleplaying games
- romance
- ron fortier
- roosters
- rosemary jones
- ross e. lockhart
- ross watson
- rothco press
- round table
- rowdy roddy piper
- rpg
- rpg's
- rural life
- ryan schifrin
- sale
- same-sex marriage
- samurai sheepdog
- satire
- save the rich
- scarred lands
- schrodinger's cat
- science
- science fantasy
- science fiction
- science fiction conventions
- science fiction convetions
- scientology
- scott r. jones
- sean taylor
- sean weiland
- seattle geekly
- selden
- self-promotion
- self-publishing
- senate
- series characters
- series fiction
- seth skorkowsky
- sex
- sexism
- sf
- sf conventions
- sf signal
- sfwa
- sfwa bulletin
- sfwa speaker's bureau
- shadow of the demon lord
- shane plays
- shane plays radio
- shared settings
- shared world fiction
- shared worlds
- shark night 3d
- shia lebeouf
- shield
- short stories
- side project podcast
- side projects podcast
- signings
- sir thomas more
- skyhorse
- smallville
- snafu
- snafu black ops
- snafu: black ops
- snafu: unnatural selection
- southern media convention
- space opera
- speaking engagements
- spectre
- spider-man
- spoof
- spooky empire
- spy fiction
- spy stories
- stabby
- stacy lung
- stacyfund@stonehill.org
- star trek
- star trek: into darkness
- star wars. humor
- state of the union address
- steampunk
- steve bannon
- steven addona
- steven kelliher
- steven ross
- stewart wieck
- stokercon
- stormtalons
- story portals
- strange new worlds
- superhero
- superhero fiction
- superhero seres
- superhero series
- superheroes
- superman
- supernatural
- supervillains
- swamp con
- swampcon
- swampcon rising
- sword and sorcery
- swordplay
- tabletop gaming awards
- talonspire
- tampa bay
- tampa bay times festival of reading
- tarot
- taxes
- technology
- ted e. grau
- television
- thac0's hammer
- thaco's hammer
- thanksgiving
- the accursed rpg
- the adversary
- the avengers
- the awakened
- the awakened ii
- the bard's tale
- the black volga
- the brotherhood of the griffon
- the captive flame
- the comics club
- the companions
- the dark knight rises
- the dead god trilogy
- the ed greenwood group
- the exploding typewriter
- the fall of cthulhu
- the fate of all fools
- the festival at glenelg
- the fishing hole
- the flash
- the genre traveler
- the ghost in the stone
- the godborn
- the gold bugs affair
- the hand of rasputin
- the haunted lands
- the hep cats of ulthar and other lovecra
- the impostor
- the king in yellow
- the lazarus effect
- the loft
- the lords of salem
- the magnificent seven
- the masked witches
- the new 52
- the new pulp
- the new pulp heroes
- the night bazaar
- the oscars
- the picture of aleister crowley
- the plague knight and other stories
- the pulps
- the pulptress
- the pulptress volme 2
- the pyramid
- the q word and other stories
- the reaver
- the republic
- the rise of the house of immur
- the shadow guide
- the sundering
- the things that crawl
- the tome show
- the tomorrow people
- the undead
- the usual questions
- the vampire's apprentice
- the voice of e
- the walking dead
- the war of the worlds
- the woman in black 2: angel of death
- the year of rogue dragons
- this sword for hire
- thomas ligotti
- thor
- thor: the dark world
- thrillers
- thumbtack
- tie=in fiction
- tim burton
- tim curran
- tim lebbon
- tim marquiz
- tim pratt
- time lord fest
- time travel
- timothy zahn
- tommy hancock
- tomorrow's cthulhu
- topless robot
- trivia
- troy denning
- tutoring
- tv
- unclean
- undead
- undercity
- university of south florida
- urban fantasy
- utopia
- valentina poly
- valentine's day
- vampire
- vampire: the masquerade
- vampires
- vendetta
- vertigo
- video
- villains
- vince foster
- vladawen
- vladawen titanslayer
- w. h. pugmire
- walking dead
- wallpaper
- web chat
- web fiction
- webcast
- weird fiction
- westerns
- when the villain comes
- when the villain comes home
- whispers from the abyss 2
- whispers from the abyss volume 2
- white wolf
- will ludwigsen
- william hatfield
- william king
- william shick
- william stiteler
- witch hunter
- witch hunter: grand tome of adversaries
- witches
- wizards of the coast
- word horde
- workshops
- world fantasy award
- world horror convention
- world horror society
- world of darkness
- worldbuilders
- wraith: the oblivion
- writer's symposium
- writers
- writing
- x comics
- x-men
- youtube
- zachary levi
- zombie
- zombie apocalypse
- zombies
- zombies in paradise
Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by
yoksel